When preparing for a Customer Success Manager (CSM) interview, knowing what to expect and being ready to demonstrate your skills and experience effectively is vital. You might have the perfect experience under your belt, but if you don’t present this correctly to your interviewer, it could cost you the job!  

As a CSM, your primary responsibility will be to ensure customer satisfaction and build lasting relationships, which requires a mix of technical, interpersonal, and problem-solving abilities. Here are some essential tips for your CSM interview preparation:

  1. Understand the company and its products or services.
  2. Familiarize yourself with typical CSM responsibilities.
  3. Prepare to discuss relevant metrics and KPIs.
  4. Be ready for technical questions.
  5. Ask thoughtful questions.

Let's begin.

1. Understand the company and its products or services

Before going for the interview, it goes without saying to thoroughly research the company and its products or services. If you turn up not knowing basic facts about the company you’re interviewing with, it’s not a great look. Try to understand the company's mission, values, target audience, and key offerings.

This knowledge will allow you to tailor your answers specifically to the company's needs and showcase your enthusiasm and dedication to the role. Check out their website, read about the use cases, read about the story of the founding team, and check out Crunchbase or LinkedIn to learn more about the stage of the company, whether it is a start-up or post-IPO (initial public offering).

2. Familiarize yourself with typical CSM responsibilities

A CSM's duties may vary depending on the company and industry, but some common responsibilities include the following:

  • Onboarding new customers
  • Training customers on products or services
  • Identifying opportunities for upselling or cross-selling
  • Monitoring customer usage and satisfaction
  • Addressing customer concerns and solving problems
  • Managing renewals

Be ready to speak about your experience and skills related to these tasks. Every organization has a slightly different approach to CS, depending on the stage of the company, the product, and the nature of the business model.

10 upselling best practices every CSM needs to know
When I first started as a Customer Success Manager (CSM), one of the most challenging parts was identifying up-sell opportunities to grow current clients. There’s no doubt that there are so many different upselling techniques.

Here’s how you can go about validating whether an opportunity is right for your skillset or simply what you are looking for next. 👇

Pre-seed stage startups

Companies in this stage are likely to need CSMs who are good at acting as the extension of the product, meaning the product isn’t mature yet and is still in the development phase. So be ready to get creative! In a pre-seed stage of a startup, you might be the person to bridge the gap in the product. This could be an excellent opportunity if you come from a solutions or technical support background.

Before an IPO/Series B+

CSMs can guide clients toward value when a product is mature and typically provide strategic advice due to their strong communication skills and executive presence. CSMs can benefit from this as they are thought leaders in the industry, advising customers on the best way to use your products.

You might have to act as a trusted advisor and commercial point of contact for your customers at this stage, as your CS function does not necessarily have renewals and enablement functions. These CS roles appeal to you if you enjoy negotiation and objection handling.

Post IPO

In this stage of maturity, companies tend to divide account management from customer success. Therefore, CSMs can spend more time preparing customers for expansion and working with them to leverage more services, such as adding more business units.

3. Prepare to discuss relevant metrics and KPIs

This is one of the parts where I see so many CSMs fail.

Ensure you’re ready to provide more information about your impact in previous roles. What was your ARR retention rate? What was the rate of upsells? How much have you grown your accounts year/quarter over quarter?  

As a CSM, you'll likely need to track and report on key performance indicators (KPIs). Familiarize yourself with KPIs such as customer churn rate, lifetime value, and net promoter score. Be prepared to discuss how you've used these or similar metrics to drive success in your previous roles.

Highlight your interpersonal skills

CSMs interact with customers daily, so showcasing your ability to communicate effectively, empathize with clients, and manage difficult situations is essential. Be prepared to share examples of when you've demonstrated these skills and your ability to collaborate with team members and stakeholders.

The most crucial interpersonal skills for any CSM or CS leader include:

  • Communication
  • Empathy
  • Relationship building
  • Active listening
  • Customer service
  • Time management
  • Problem-solving
  • Decision-making
Why collaboration will transform your customer experiences
I’m going to be forthright: the world we’re living in can no longer exist without an excellent customer experience. It sounds harsh, but it’s now a reality. Many organizations fail due to their inability to deliver seamless customer experiences.

Prepare for behavioral questions

Interviewers often ask behavioral questions to understand how you would handle specific situations. Think about instances where you've solved complex customer issues, mitigated customer churn, or turned a dissatisfied customer into a happy one.

Practice explaining these situations using the STAR method to structure your responses:

⭐️ Situation

⭐️ Task

⭐️ Action

⭐️ Result

Here are a few customer success interview questions you can prepare for:

Q: Tell me about a challenge or conflict you faced at your past/current job. How did you handle it?

A: At my previous job, one of the major challenges I faced was when a client was unhappy with the implementation of a software solution, citing issues with its usability and integration with their existing systems.

To address the situation, I initiated a meeting with the client to discuss their concerns in detail. I then collaborated with our development team to prioritize and address those concerns. By maintaining open communication with the client throughout the process, we were able to deliver a more satisfactory solution, ultimately leading to a stronger, long-lasting relationship.

Q: Tell me about a time you had to change.

A: I had to adapt when our company introduced a new customer relationship management (CRM) system.

Initially, I found it challenging to transition from the old system to the new one, as it required learning a new interface and adjusting to a different way of tracking customer interactions. However, I recognized the potential benefits of the new system and dedicated time to attending training sessions and seeking help from colleagues.

Ultimately, I became proficient in the new CRM, which allowed me to manage customer relationships more effectively.

Scaling customer success: 3 challenges facing B2B CSM teams
Within customer success, you’ll often hear people say “I’d love to scale my CS program and make it more proactive than reactive”, in fact, it’s probably something you’d like to do for your own organization.

Q: Tell me about a time when you had to come up with a creative solution to solve a problem.

A: One time, a client faced a tight deadline to launch a new product, but they were having difficulties with the onboarding process.

I proposed a tailored, accelerated onboarding program by focusing on the most critical elements of the process and delivering personalized support through video conferencing and chat. This creative approach enabled the client to meet their deadline and ensured a smooth launch.

Q: Tell me about a time you created something from nothing.

A: In my previous role, I noticed that our team lacked a structured process for tracking and evaluating customer feedback. I took the initiative to create a comprehensive feedback management system from scratch.

This included developing a feedback form, establishing a process for gathering and analyzing the data, and setting up regular team meetings to discuss insights and improvements. This system helped us identify areas for improvement and resulted in higher customer satisfaction.

Q: Tell me about your most significant achievements in your past work.

A: One of my most significant achievements was when I managed a high-profile client's onboarding process. They had complex requirements and a tight timeline, but I was able to coordinate resources, communicate effectively with the client, and ensure a successful implementation. As a result, the client became a major advocate for our company, leading to several referrals and a substantial increase in revenue.

Q: Tell me about the last time you failed and what happened.

A: During a software rollout for a client, I underestimated the amount of training and support required for their team. As a result, the client's staff struggled with the new system, which led to delays and frustration. I took responsibility for the oversight and immediately arranged additional training and support resources. This experience taught me the importance of thoroughly assessing a client's needs and tailoring our approach to meet them.

Customer success and cross-departmental collaboration
We all know that effective collaboration is the key to success in any organization. However, sometimes collaborating across departments is easier said than done.

Q: Tell me about a time when you had a conflict with a coworker. How did you resolve it?

A: I had a disagreement with a colleague regarding the prioritization of support requests from our clients. My coworker believed that all requests should be treated equally, while I believed in prioritizing based on urgency and potential impact. To resolve the conflict, we had an open and respectful discussion to understand each other's perspectives.

We ultimately agreed on a hybrid approach that combined both our ideas, resulting in a more efficient and effective support process.

LinkedIn interview preparation services offer some excellent curated example answers from different roles including customer success to draft up your answers when preparing for your interviews.

4. Be ready to answer technical questions

As a Customer Success Manager (CSM), your role will often involve technical and non-technical aspects. During an interview, you can expect to be asked technical questions to gauge your understanding of the company's products, technologies, and ability to troubleshoot issues. Some common technical questions that you might encounter include:

  • Can you describe the technology stack our company uses, and how it contributes to the success of our customers?
  • How would you explain our product or service to a non-technical customer in simple terms?
  • Can you walk us through troubleshooting a common technical issue our customers might face, step-by-step?
  • What's your experience with CRM platforms like Salesforce or HubSpot? How have you used these platforms to track customer success metrics?
  • How would you handle a situation where a customer is facing a technical issue that is not documented in the knowledge base?
  • Can you describe a time when you had to work with a technical team to resolve a customer issue? How did you collaborate with them, and what was the outcome?
Transitioning from a non-CS background into customer success
Taking the first step in your customer success career is an experience every CS professional takes at one time or another. No one’s born into a job (trust-fund babies aside), and most are likely moved around until they find the right fit.
  • How do you stay current on updates to our products or services? How do you ensure customers know these updates and can utilize them effectively?
  • Can you explain the difference between SaaS, PaaS, and IaaS and how these concepts relate to our company's offerings?
  • How familiar are you with APIs, and how might you assist a customer in integrating our API into their system?
  • What strategies would you use to identify and prioritize product enhancements based on customer feedback?
  • Can you tell me about a time when you used data points to tell a story to your customer about a potential upsell or expansion opportunity?

Although you may not be expected to have a deep understanding of the technical aspects of the product or service, having a solid foundation in the relevant technologies will allow you to communicate effectively with customers and collaborate with other teams to ensure customer success.

5. Ask thoughtful questions

At the end of the interview, you'll likely have the opportunity to ask questions. Prepare a list of insightful queries demonstrating your company knowledge and interest in the role. Here are the top three Customer Success Manager questions to ask the interviewer:

  • What types of skills is the team missing that you’re looking to fill with a new hire?
  • What metrics or goals will my performance be evaluated against?
  • What challenges do CSMs commonly face, and how can they be overcome?

All in all

Preparing for a CSM interview involves understanding the company and its offerings, showcasing your interpersonal and problem-solving skills, and being ready to discuss relevant metrics and experiences. By following these tips, you'll be well on your way to acing your Customer Success Manager interview and confidently starting your new role.

Level up

Did you know that 78% of customer success professionals said that taking a learning and development course has had a positive impact on their careers?

If you're looking to level up and bag your next CS role, why not make sure your resumé truly sparkles with a customer success certification?

With a whole range of expert-led courses ranging from customer retention to metrics to advocacy to leadership, there's something there for everyone at all levels of seniority.

You never know, it might just be the difference between an offer and a rejection.